This is one of a series of posts in which we grade each team’s wily hot stove maneuvers and tragic offseason blunders.

As we know, “Milwaukee” is Algonquin for “the good land.” And Milwaukee does indeed look like the good land in 2008. Last year they ended up leading the NL Central for all but 29 games, only to falter in August and cede first place to the powerhouse 85-win Cubs. But this year will be different. Why?

Dreeeeeaaaaamweaver....First, there’s the hotly anticipated full season of Dreamy-Eyed Ryan Braun. Then there’s the fact that the Brewers finally took my advice (preen, preen) and moved the defensively challenged Braun out of the left side of the infield and into the left side of the outfield. Then there’s the fact that he’s just 24.

Then, there’s Prince Fielder, who, while the baseball world’s attention was focused on the dreamy eyes of the aforementioned Dreamy-Eyed One, hit 50 homers last year. He’s still only 23.

And then there’s Rickie Weeks, who spent most of last year struggling as he recovered from wrist surgery he’d had in August 2006—but who went on a tear the last two months of the season, and who’ll be leading off on Opening Day. He poised for a breakout season at age 25.

Hopes are also high for 21-year old starter Yovani Gallardo, who did quite well in his debut last year. Gallardo has been lights-out at every level, and should be ready to take on a full workload this year, despite his tender age. He’s got a fastball in the mid-90s and a big curveball in the 70s, and in September of last year, he put together a 21-inning scoreless streak with the big league club. He’ll likely be joined in the starting rotation by another young hurler, Carlos Villanueva, giving Milwaukee’s rotation a youthful new look.

Gallardo is also reasonably dreamy.Finally, 30-year old Ben Sheets is healthy and ready to have a good year, after a few seasons sprinkled with injuries. He’s in the last year of his contract and would no doubt like to prove himself worthy of big money; if he stays healthy, that shouldn’t be a problem. Over the past three years, he hasn’t pitched more than 156.2 innings per season, but his K/BB rate and his ERA have been decent over that span. Plus, the last time he was in a contract year, he pitched 237 innings with a 2.70 ERA and a ridiculous 237 strikeouts. If he can get even a little close to those numbers again, the Brewers will have a formidable 1-2 punch at the top of their rotation.

Yet despite all the good news, there are still some lingering concerns and question marks heading into camp.

The Brewers landed Gabe Kapler this winter, who is making a return to the majors after a year spent managing Boston’s Single-A club, the Greenville (SC) Drive. This upped the team’s already high dreaminess quotient considerably, and, more to the point, gives them the extra outfielder they need. Their preferred starting CF, Gold Glover Mike Cameron, starting the year serving a 25-game suspension after testing positive for a banned stimulant after last season, his second failed test. In his absence, centerfield will be staffed by Tony Gwynn Jr and Gabe Gross. Corey Hart platooned in right field last year, but Brewers brass seems to be going into Spring Training thinking of him as an everyday guy. Once Cameron returns, however, the Brewers will have six outfielders. Someone will have to go to the minors, or become trade bait.

But the outfield is just one issue still facing the Brewers. The bigger question is the bullpen. New closer Eric Gagne showed up in the Mitchell Report, and has yet to publicly comment on it; but, more alarmingly from the point of view of those paying him $10 million, he has yet to show he can still be an effective pitcher. With the Rangers last year, Gagne seemed to hold is own; but with the Red Sox, he fell so completely apart that he almost single-handedly cost them the division title. If Gagne goes back on the roids miraculously improves, Milwaukee’s expensive gamble will look canny. If he stays true to form, however, they’ll have made a very expensive, all-too-predictable mistake.

GM Doug Melvin also traded for reliever Guillermo Mota this offseason, who served a 50-game ban last year for failing a steroid test, and Salomon Torres, as well as signing free agents Randy Choate and David Riske (which has always seemed, to me, like a terrible last name for relief pitcher). None of those guys is going to cause dancing in the streets of Milwaukee. Unfortunately, try though Melvin might, there’s just no way to replace a set-up-man and closer combo of Scott Linebrink and Francisco Cordero—and no way for the Brewers to keep both of them. But despite the criticism of Linebrink’s four-year deal with the White Sox, $4.75 million a year isn’t that much for a set-up man. I admit that four years is a long time to commit to a reliever, and that the fact that Linebrink has a no-trade clause is preposterous, but despite talk of his “decline,” he’s still only 31. Couldn’t the Brewers have scooped him up for a lesser deal before other teams were allowed to negotiate with him? It’s not like they’re a tiny market team; their payroll is just shy of $80 million a year.

Looking ahead, their best prospect is another Fielder/Braun type named Matt LaPorta, another masher with no defense. But with Fielder at first base and Braun now in left field, the Brewers are running out of places to stash these guys. If I were the Brewers, once LaPorta has more professional games under his belt, I might find an AL team looking for a young DH and try to make a trade.

Projected Lineup, Rotation, and Closer

1. 2B Rickie Weeks – 16 HR, .374 OBP

2. SS J.J. Hardy – 26 HR, 30 2B, .277 AVG

3. 1B Prince Fielder – 50 HR, 1.013 OPS

4. LF Ryan Braun – 34 HR, .370 OBP

5. RF Corey Hart – 24 HR, .298 AVG

6. 3B Bill Hall – 14 HR, 35 2B, .254 AVG

7. CF Mike Cameron – 21 HR, .328 OBP

8. C Jason Kendall – .301 OBP, .309 SLG

SP1 Ben Sheets, 3.82 ERA, .253 BAA

SP2 Yovani Gallardo, 3.67 ERA, 1.27 WHIP

SP3 Carlos Villanueva, 3.95 ERA, .236 BAA

SP4 Jeff Suppan, 4.62 ERA

SP5 Dave Bush/Chris Capuano/Claudio Vargas/Manny Parra

CL: Eric Gagne

Acquisitions: Mike Cameron (CF), Eric Gagne (RP), Jason Kendall (C), David Riske (RP), Guillermo Mota (RP), Salomon Torres (RP), Gabe Kapler (OF)

Losses: Francisco Cordero (RP), Geoff Jenkins (LF), Scott Linebrink (RP), Matt Wise (RP), Johnny Estrada, (C).


The Brewers will score runs with their speed and power, and their starting rotation looks solid. They’ll have several guys competing for the starters’ slots in camp, including lefty prospect Manny Parra. Shifting Braun to left field and Bill Hall to third base, and acquiring Cameron, should give the Brewers’ defense a needed boost. There’s been some disagreement about the deal for catcher Jason Kendall, but he moved back towards his career averages in the second half of last season. I see upside there. However, I have to dock the Brewers some points for gambling money they can’t afford to waste on Gagne. I suppose someone was going to sign him, but I can’t believe he commanded 10 million dollars. Were they out-bidding some other team?? Plus, I can’t help but notice that not only have they signed three guys with PED problems, but their farm system is no cleaner: of their top five prospects, one’s been slapped with a 50-game suspension for using PEDs, and another has been caught smoking pot multiple times. And then there’s the way they picked up Manager Ned Yost’s contract option, but forgot to announce it. Despite their decent offseason, it just feels like the Brewers don’t quite have their house in order.

But the bottom line is that the Brewers are a young club that, last year, broke a 15-year streak of sub-.500 seasons, broke a franchise home run record, and broke the Brewers’ attendance record. They’ve got solid pitching and great offensive ability. Their greatest weakness last year was their horrible defense, which they have addressed this winter about as well as could be hoped. This year, if a few of their pitching gambles work out, they could definitely make the playoffs.

Hot Offseason Action Index

8 Responses to “Hot Offseason Action: Milwaukee Brewers”

  1. mets got wise not brews

  2. Nick Kapur says:

    Yeah, metts, that’s why he’s listed under “losses.”

  3. Nick Kapur says:

    I have to say that despite the Kendall and Gagne signings, which I have to question, this is the most exciting Brewers team in years. Actually, I’m pretty sure this is the most exciting Brewers team ever.

    Ryan Braun and Prince Fielder get most of the publicity, but JJ Hardy, Corey Hart, and Yovani “Lamborghini” Gallardo also quietly had breakout years last season, and Bill Hall and Richie Weeks also appear to be legitimate major league stars. And we already know how good Ben Sheets can be, if he is actually healthy. All that and a full season of Ryan Braun’s batting should have Brewers fans positively giddy with excitement, if they have any giddiness left to gid with after all those years of bedragglement.

  4. Sheets has never won over 12 games in a season, ever. It’s wishful thinking for him to be able to complete a full season healthy. Kendall only threw out 4% of base runners last year so he probably can’t be any worse, right? Fielder and Braun are legit stars on the rise but Weeks and Hall? I fail to see where they have shown star potential. The Brew Crew may still be a year or two away.

  5. Sarah Green says:

    Sheets has thrown at least 200 innings three times. He had many quality starts during that span that didn’t get converted into wins, thanks to a shitty team behind him. With this offense, that won’t be problem.

  6. IF Ben Sheets can make 30 starts and IF Rickie Weeks finally lives up to expectations, and IF Yovani Gallardo is the real deal, then I can see the Brewers taking the division. But I still think that the Cubs are two or three games better than Milwaukee. It’ll be a close race, I think, though.

  7. Nick Kapur says:

    Yeah, I agree with Paul that the Cubs are probably the favorite in that division. But Melissa, as a Cubs fan, you would be foolish to discount the Brewers’ chances completely. Remember that they actually led that division for the vast majority of last season, before the Cubs finally caught them, and this year all of their young players have another year’s worth of experience under their belts. I think it will be a much closer race than Cubs fans would ideally want to have.

  8. I certainly don’t dismiss the Brewers by any stretch. They should definitely contend for the division title this season. I do think the Cubs hold an edge due to having veteran players that have performed more consistently. Right now, for this season I will take Lee and Ramirez over Fielder and Braun but that may soon change. I also think the Cubs defense and pitching is stronger overall. The main reason it was close last season was because the Cubs struggled the first two months with new players that were out of position and Piniella had to learn his roster and how it fit together. I certainly wouldn’t be shocked if the Brewers took it this year but I think they are going to be stronger in 1 or 2 seasons from now when some of their young pitching matures. I still don’t think they can count on Sheets, he hasn’t pitched over 200 innings since 2004. He has been to the Brewers what Prior and Wood have been to the Cubs. I can also say that after watching Kendall play last season that I’m glad he’s playing for them.

Leave a Reply

    Recent Comments

    • planet hobbywood: This is very interesting.
    • Bren: He is a awesome player and a good man.. sweet.. polite.. friendly.. down to earth.. he never acted as though he...
    • HADAJUN( Japanese): Okajima a Japanese hero?
    • Rickt: I am the biggest Cal Jr fan around but one of my good friends played minor league baseball in the Orioles...
    • HADAJUN: I wish for play in Japan. The death is regrettable.


    Subscribe via email

    Enter your email address:


Featured posts

December 5, 2011

Will anybody get elected to the Hall of Fame this year?

Last week, we asked you to vote for who you would like to see enshrined in baseball’s Hall of Fame. The verdict? If it were up to UmpBump readers, nobody would make it in. The leading vote getter (so far) is Jeff Bagwell, who has 60% support. Of course, in the real voting, players need […]

January 5, 2011

Annual UmpBump Hall of Fame Balloting: 2011 Edition

In what has become an annual tradition, we here at UmpBump cast our ballots for the Hall of Fame on the eve of the announcements of the voting for the real Hall of Fame. Voters can vote for anyone ever who has been retired from baseball for at least five years and is not already […]

October 19, 2010

Crowdsourcing the Greats: The Top 10 Managers of All Time

Now that we’ve looked at every position on the diamond, as well as relief pitchers, we are nearing the end of our “Crowdsourcing the Greats” series. But before we finish, let’s turn one more time to the internet hoi polloi for answers on who the greatest baseball manager of all time was. As usual, we […]