• HaroldHecuba: Mike Mussina is EASTERN EUROPEAN, not Italian....

We’ve done the ugliest uniforms and the crazy old-school uniforms—but what about the unis that actually look good? Here, your All-Star lineup of the nine best-looking get-ups in the majors:

1. Yankees. Other teams wear pinstripes. But the Yankees wear Pinstripes. In fact, “pinstripes” has become something of a metonym for the New York Yankees. For instance, if a premiere free agent came on the market and Hank Steinbrenner was jingling the change in his pocket, a pundit might comment by saying, “before you know it, he’ll be in pinstripes,” or words to that effect. In addition, in an age that sees many a major league team putting numbers on the front of their jerseys, or—horror of horrors—player names on the back of their home whites, the Yankees remain the only team in MLB without player names even on their out-of-town uniforms. Love them or hate them, you have to admit that is badass.

2. Tigers. Boston Globe columnist Dan Shaughnessy once described their home uniforms in a column as “baseball tuxedos.” It was a rare moment of accord between Mr. Shaughnessy and myself. No other term better describes the simple elegance of Detroit’s black and white duds. And the away unis with the midnight blue and just a dash of orange? Brilliant!

3. A’s. First, the A’s get bonus points for venturing out of the safe, overdone area of red-white-blue uniforms. Yet they also manage to steer clear of the unfortunate teal-purple-turquoise realm. Oakland’s sunny yellow and forest green is distinctive, attractive, and appropriate for NoCal. (Additionally, many of the team’s players are themselves more attractive than average. This increases the aesthetics of their uniforms.) I know they catch a lot of flak for their white cleats, but I actually think the white looks better than the alternatives—especially when they wear their socks up, displaying a pleasing contrast between green sock and white shoe. In fact, I would like Oakland to consider making this a mandatory thing, because when the players don’t wear their socks up, and choose to go instead with a baggy, full-length pantleg, white blends into white and they end up looking like they’re wearing footie pajamas.

4. Giants. The black and orange? Hot. The interlocking “SF” logo on the cap? Very nice. The understated, sans serif font across the chest? Tres chic. Plus, the home whites with their bolder, more ornate typeface are also an easy hardball classic. They may lose the most games of any team in the majors this year, but they’ll look damn good doing it.

5. Pirates. The duds are simple, elegant, and distinctive. This is a rare example of a vest uniform actually working. (Plus, they get props for their piratical insignia. Pirates are so hot right now. Arrrr!) And unlike Colorado, Pittsburgh knows that if you’re going to go with pinstripes, you can’t add a lot of other elements—you’ve got to keep it clean and simple. The yellow really pops on the away grays, almost like a ray of sunny hope piercing a gloomy sky—all too appropriate for a beleaguered organization from a city that’s seen better days.

6. Dodgers. The Dodgers’ uniform is a statement. They want you to know that they are a classy, classic, all-American organization with a proud history. On another team, this uniform would be a bit too safe—maybe even boring. But because they’re the Dodgers, it just looks just right.

7. White Sox. Teams with too many crazy colors, take note: it’s really, really hard to look bad when you go with black and white. The White Sox are the third team on this list who dress in shades of gray. The simple “sock” patch on the sleeve, the elegant piping on the leg, the classic cursive script across the chest—everything works together seamlessly. In fact, all of Chicago’s various uniforms look equally good. No easy feat. Thus, this play on the right may look hideous, but the White Sox still look dapper.

8. Red Sox. The Red Sox have a clean, classic uniform. I personally liked their old socks a bit better—ridiculous, striped affairs that made one feel as if Ted Williams and Jimmy Foxx were somewhere just out of sight—but I do recognize the thematic consistency in having the Red Sox wear red socks. Red and white are over-used in the world of MLB uniforms (Reds, Angels, Cardinals, Phillies, Twins, Astros), but unlike some of their red-and-white compatriots, the Red Sox never take the field looking like a bunch of tomatoes, strawberries, or other overly red produce, thanks in part to the navy hats. (Red + navy = a fine New England tradition.) I only wish they’d kept the navy undershirts from a few seasons back. But the real tipping point here is the font. The font is so easily recognizable, it’s become synonymous with Boston itself. Not too many baseball uniforms have that on their resume. The one hitch is that nearly all of the Boston players are hirsute, pine-tar covered slobs who wear their unis several sizes too large. Thus, to see the Red Sox uniform as God intended, I have here chosen a picture of Jacoby Ellsbury.

9. Cubs. I love the bear cub. I love the bold, crisp “C” logo. I don’t super-love the pinstripes—the Cubs’ bold colors and clean logos don’t need it. It’s not a deal-breaker, but if they’d gone with a nice blue-and-red piping down the leg instead, the Cubs would be higher on my list. Yes, red-white-and-blue is overdone, but the Cubs do it very well. Even when the ivy hasn’t leafed yet.

Bench players

Indians. We like the everything-old-is-new-again look they’re sporting as an alternate uni this year, and I like their regular unis quite a bit. But I have to take points off for their insistence on retaining Chief Wahoo as their logo. I have no problem with the team’s name, but that cartoon character looks like something out of the 50s. Oh wait…it is.

Phillies. Philadelphia’s new alternate home uniforms are the hotness. The red-white-and-blue works well for the city of Ben Franklin and the Liberty Bell. The uniform is clean and classic, but not boring, thanks to the two little stars over the i’s and thanks to the slick piping down the outseam. The reason they don’t crack my starting lineup? They don’t wear this kickass alternate uni nearly enough.

Nationals. I love what they’re trying to do here, but it feels like there’s just too much going on—right down to the two competing logos. (One of these, the cursive “W”, looks like a pig’s tail, for crying out loud. They need to stick with the interlocking D and C.) There’s red, there’s blue, there’s yellow. The various uniforms don’t seem to have any bearing on each other, as if the Nats were that old Washington team, the Senators, and they were polling their constituents to see which look they should wear. I like the font they’ve used for the “Washington” across the chest, but they’ve made it look a bit cluttered by using two colors for it. In the words of Henry David Thoreau: simplify, simplify.

A few tips to ballplayers who want to increase the attractiveness of their uniforms: don’t wear the belt too high (yes, we’re thinking of you, JULIO LUGO!). Pull up your socks and show a little calf. Wear pants that fit—don’t go too tight (unless you’re very sure you’ve got the ass for it), but don’t go too loose or it will look sloppy. Finally, I know some of these early spring night games are chilly, but if you’re going to go with an undershirt, treat yourself to a nice fitted underarmor job instead of a wrinkly, bulky old turtleneck.

What do you think, Umpbumpers?

Oh, and if you pick “other,” I think you owe us a comment explaining who we missed. Thanks!

34 Responses to “Nine Best Baseball Uniforms”

  1. Maybe…just maybe…you’re wrong about this one when it comes to the Cardinals uniform.

    First of all, the STL logo is arguably the best in baseball. It’s been around for a hundred years and still looks great.

    Second, To put teams like the A’s with that barf green and yellow over the Redbirds is a travesty. How can classic Red and White be wrong.

    Last, so many people (especially non-Cards fans) think the jerseys are great, as you can see from the comments here. Maybe starring at those Oakland jerseys has fried your brain.

  2. Sarah Green says:

    Whoah, Dave, whoah! You’ve gone into crazy-serious mode. That’s not the mode in which we discuss the all-important issue of baseball uniforms, at least not here at UmpBump. It’s my list and the Redbirds unis make me laugh. It’s just a matter of taste! I’m well aware that I’m in the minority, but it’s not a democratic list—that’s what the poll at the end of the post and this robust comments section are for.

    Though I just have to say, if you barf forest green, then you should call your doctor. Immediately.

  3. I really like the Marlins uniforms.

  4. Swell article,

    In lieu of Jacoby Elsbury (an excellent player) I would have used Jason Varitek i.e. pants up and his Red Socks proudly showing.

    Take care,

    Brendan

  5. Another great article.

    It was a tough choice voting for just one. I nearly went with the Red Sox – I love the crispness of the white, the rather subtle piping and the lettering is just swell.

    In the end there could only be one winner for me and I went with the A’s. They were one of the teams in the first game of baseball I saw and although I didn’t become a fan, I’ve always held a soft spot for both the organisation and the unis.

    The colours work well together, the logo is good as well as the lettering on the jersey.

    My Mets were not mentioned so I’ll do so here:

    Love the white uni sans pinstripe; love the grey away, love the black alt as well. The use of the blue with the orange outline just does it for me

    Also, totally agree with Sarah about the Cardinal logo. What a load of sh**. Sorry Cards fans, but I’ve always thought it looked rather naff

  6. The Brewers GLOVE (MB) logo is arguably the best logo ever. I’m not crazy about their unis though.

  7. The best years for baseball uniforms were 1978-1979.
    Baseball uniforms have been boring for so long.

  8. You’re out of your mind.

    - Yankees at #1 is correct.
    - The Tigers wear navy, not black (same with the Yanks).
    - The A’s have a great green and keep the yellow to a minimum, which is good, but the white cleats are terrible, ESPECIALLY when guys show their socks. I don’t have a good answer for what they should wear (green cleats can’t be right), but the white is rough.
    - The Giants? C’mon. Two ugly colors never combine to be attractive.
    - The White Sox should be higher on the list for having 4 awesome looks. All pins, black/pins, all gray, black/gray. The all look great.
    - The Cubs pins are great. The all gray uniforms are among the worst in baseball.
    - Dodgers are classic. It’s the same league as Detroit and St. Louis. It’s bold and tough to go with no piping, and all 3 of those teams make it happen. Gotta put Stl on the list.

  9. AAAAARRRGGGHHH!!!!!! its NOT nocal! its norcal, dammit! people from norcal cal it norcal! so please dont call it nocal!

  10. Nick Kapur says:

    Yeah, but everyone else calls it NoCal. Including the people in SoCal.

  11. Good list.. I agree the STL cards should have been in the top 10 and I also like the road jerseys of the Texas Rangers.

  12. No offense, but you are nuts. Not going to waste my time, trying to explain. any real fan would pick a classic, with real style.

    The Cardinals in a landslide. Not even on your list? Nuff said.

  13. HelmetHead says:

    Gotta agree with the Redbirds fans, even though I’m not one. Yeah, it’s your list, but any list that omits the Cards is suspect. The Yanks are the clear number one for classic unis, with the Cards having to be second, third, or at the very least top five.

    The Athletics’ white spikes are horrendous; alway have been, always will be. This isn’t football.

    Yes, as Chad points out, the Tigers wear navy, not black. It’s midnight navy, same color as the Yanks.

    The White Sox’ unis are okay, but not great. A little boring. They would get major points if they brought back the old Sox logo that was a big S with the O and X inside of the curves of the S. The reason I would knock the Sox off the list, though, is that they are singularly responsible for starting the worst current uniform trend in baseball: the black alternate jersey. Thankfully, that trend is on the wane, but it was horrible at its peak, and the remnants still remain.

  14. Geez, why do I keep seeing this…the Tigers’ color is NAVY, NOT BLACK!!!!!

Leave a Reply

Marketplace

    Subscribe via email

    Enter your email address:

    Archives

What's Popular

Featured posts

220px-Bbwaa_logo_web

December 5, 2011

Will anybody get elected to the Hall of Fame this year?

Last week, we asked you to vote for who you would like to see enshrined in baseball’s Hall of Fame. The verdict? If it were up to UmpBump readers, nobody would make it in. The leading vote getter (so far) is Jeff Bagwell, who has 60% support. Of course, in the real voting, players need […]

January 5, 2011

Annual UmpBump Hall of Fame Balloting: 2011 Edition

In what has become an annual tradition, we here at UmpBump cast our ballots for the Hall of Fame on the eve of the announcements of the voting for the real Hall of Fame. Voters can vote for anyone ever who has been retired from baseball for at least five years and is not already […]

According to the internet, "The Little Napoleon" John McGraw was the greatest manager of all time.

October 19, 2010

Crowdsourcing the Greats: The Top 10 Managers of All Time

Now that we’ve looked at every position on the diamond, as well as relief pitchers, we are nearing the end of our “Crowdsourcing the Greats” series. But before we finish, let’s turn one more time to the internet hoi polloi for answers on who the greatest baseball manager of all time was. As usual, we […]