Andy Pettitte has decided to retire, and an ESPN Stats article suggests he might be a Hall of Famer:

[I]f he wants to be enshrined, he may have to get in line behind Jack Morris (who received 53.5 percent of votes in 2010 and was not elected in his 12th year of eligibility). But when you use ERA+, a stat designed to adjust ERA for ballpark and league average, it shows that Pettitte was superior to Morris and nearly identical to future inductee Bert Blyleven (ERA+ comes from Baseball Reference).

ERA+ is a great stat. But it’s not the only stat. And it’s a little silly to suggest Pettitte and Blyleven were equals. Blyleven had a career WAR of nearly 90, while Pettitte was around 50. Also, Blyleven had over 3700 Ks, while Pettitte only had 2200.

Jayson Stark, as only he can do, recently looked at a ton of stats and came to the same conclusion I did — Pettitte was very good, but not Hall-worthy.

Of course, that doesn’t mean Pettitte won’t make it in. There is a long and hallowed tradition of electing Yankees to the Hall of Fame who were pretty okay and won a lot of championships because their teammates were great. Guys like Tony Lazzeri and Phil Rizzuto.  So I’m not going to count Pettitte out. But if they do elect him they might as well rename it “The Hall of Great Players and Yankee Players Who Were Pretty Good.”

*Nick Kapur contributed to this post.

2 Responses to “Pettitte not quite Hall-worthy”

  1. Well, it’s called the Hall of Fame, not the Hall of Objective Greatness. He’s a True Yankee, dammit!

Leave a Reply

    Recent Comments

    • planet hobbywood: This is very interesting.
    • Bren: He is a awesome player and a good man.. sweet.. polite.. friendly.. down to earth.. he never acted as though he...
    • HADAJUN( Japanese): Okajima a Japanese hero?
    • Rickt: I am the biggest Cal Jr fan around but one of my good friends played minor league baseball in the Orioles...
    • HADAJUN: I wish for play in Japan. The death is regrettable.


    Subscribe via email

    Enter your email address:


Featured posts

December 5, 2011

Will anybody get elected to the Hall of Fame this year?

Last week, we asked you to vote for who you would like to see enshrined in baseball’s Hall of Fame. The verdict? If it were up to UmpBump readers, nobody would make it in. The leading vote getter (so far) is Jeff Bagwell, who has 60% support. Of course, in the real voting, players need […]

January 5, 2011

Annual UmpBump Hall of Fame Balloting: 2011 Edition

In what has become an annual tradition, we here at UmpBump cast our ballots for the Hall of Fame on the eve of the announcements of the voting for the real Hall of Fame. Voters can vote for anyone ever who has been retired from baseball for at least five years and is not already […]

October 19, 2010

Crowdsourcing the Greats: The Top 10 Managers of All Time

Now that we’ve looked at every position on the diamond, as well as relief pitchers, we are nearing the end of our “Crowdsourcing the Greats” series. But before we finish, let’s turn one more time to the internet hoi polloi for answers on who the greatest baseball manager of all time was. As usual, we […]